They have little packs of stuff at Starbucks like the new Lime Cooler drink mix, or the Via packs, and of course mugs, I love their mugs.
I like the idea about the 5 and Under store, they have tons of stuff.
I know you said no lotions, but how about scented hand sanitizers?
Might sound weird, but those little gift wrapping tape dispensers, perfect for the time of year. Very useful.
Inexpensive kitchen stuff like pot holders, those little bowls you use to prep before you cook, I have this little shot glass that shows you how much a Tablespoon or teaspoon or ounce is with lines on the side that I absolutely love, those rubber grippy things that open jars.
Thumb drives, sometimes they sell for under $10.
A workout dvd from Mary's sale!