I had this set (but traded it) but they were some of the most scratched up DVDs I've ever seen. I have plenty of systems that came in the cardboard holders, but these seemed to be wedged in there extremely tight, to the point that there was almost no way to take them out without scratching them, unless you tore the cardboard
Other systems that come packaged this way seem to have more room in the sleeve for the DVD to slide out fairly easily. This is not why I traded the set though, lol, I just didn't click with it.
I didn't send mine back as they all played fine, and the person I traded with knew of the issue. I kept the receipt just in case she wanted to return them, but it looks like the issue never got resolved so I don't know how much good it would do to return them for a new set unless they change their packaging.