|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes |
10-26-12, 04:19 AM | |
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: NH
|
Three days a week for three months, the women focused on exercises that would strengthen the biceps and the latissimus dorsi — the large back muscle that is activated during the exercise. They lifted weights and used an incline to practice a modified pull-up, raising themselves up to a bar, over and over, in hopes of strengthening the muscles they would use to perform the real thing. They also focused on aerobic training to lower body fat.
If you want to be able to do pull-ups you need to practice pull-ups. Seems to me that they approximated pull-ups without ever having them practice the upright true and honest movement. I can't help but wonder if the outcome would have been different had they actually incorporated modified upright pull-ups progressing to less and less assistance. Three weeks is also not a very long time to build up the kind of upper body and core strength you need for a pull-up.
__________________
Lannette See my profile for info on relationships with various video distributors. Do you really want to look back on your life and see how wonderful it could have been had you not been afraid to live it? - Caroline Myss |
10-26-12, 06:23 AM | |
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: South Jersey
|
I would like to read the study before commenting on it (maybe over the weekend). However my own opinion on the matter is that bodyweight DOES matter, as do lever arms, among other things. I have long arms and somewhat hypermobile shoulders, and I have found that two things influence my ability to do pull ups; 1) my weight and 2) doing pull ups. I have to do them to be able to do them. If I haven't been doing them consistently I have to default to negatives or bands to bang out any kind of serious numbers. After doing that consistently for a good while, I can do sets without.
As for lat pulldowns - I don't think they're a strict analogue for pullups. As Ivy stated (and as you will figure out if you even do a set of slow-ish negatives) there is a LOT more core involvement than you might think. I recall doing negatives for the first time some number of years ago and having the WORST ab DOMS for days after! I think if your shoulders are healthy enough to do them they're a worthwhile addition to your training arsenal - even if you have to work hard to get there.
__________________
The Grim Reaper catches us all. But when he catches me the son-of-a-bitch is going to be hunched over, wheezing and gasping for breath! Certified Bulletproof Athlete |
10-26-12, 07:10 AM | |
Join Date: Apr 2002
|
I went from no pull ups to doing 2 sets of 12 pull ups and a third set of 5-6 pull ups. It wasn't a big plan but what I was doing was first, 12 weeks of NROL4W, then 4 1/2 month rotation of Cathe's STS program. When I couldn't do pull ups, I did lat pull downs with my hands in wide, narrow, palms up, palms down positions, negative pull downs on my pull up bar, pull ups starting on a step stool with my tip toe of one foot on it etc. I do feel strongly that all those variations of push ups that Cathe does in STS chest work did help condition my body for pull ups too.
I agree that pull ups totally worked my abs and the whole front side of my core. If you can't do pull ups, try chin ups, which are much easier. My DD is another one who could just bang out a million chin ups and pull ups. She could outdo almost every, if not all, of the boys on her swim team. She has long arms and legs, as does my dh and I. My DH is 6' but his arms measure 6'2" from end to end. My DD is 5'7" and her arms measure 5'9" from end to end. My arms are longer than my height too, I just don't remember what they measured but I'm almost 5'7". Maybe I don't care about my arm length so much because I'm a runner! |
10-26-12, 08:17 AM | |
Community Manager
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Northern VA, USA
|
After about 3 rounds of P90X I think my personal best was 5 unassisted chin ups and maybe 3 unassisted pull-ups. It was a great feeling to get to that point, but it took a lot of work and many weeks to get there. A few weeks definitely isn't enough for most people, I expect.
Also, unless I'm training chin-ups/pull-ups regularly, I lose the ability VERY quickly, so I am not surprised that women who were not specifically practicing pull ups couldn't do any.
__________________
Wendy Niemi Kremer Community Manager DISCLOSURE: I have a professional relationship with a seller or producer of fitness videos or products. For details, please see my profile. |
Tags |
katy bowman, pull ups, pullups |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|